[meteorite-list] Dr. Bunch's Latest on NWA 1839/3133

[David Weir]

Adam Hupe wrote:
> My last post on the subject,
> 
> I just had a lengthy conversation with Dr. Bunch just as few minutes ago 
> about the non-paired stones NWA 1839/3133.
> 
> Some statements made by Dr. Bunch:
> 
> He absolutely and unequivocally disagrees with David Weir's last post 
> the List.
> 
> He has access to the latest data and it in no way supports a pairing 
> between the two.
> 
> Dr Bunch's exact quote "The petrography, mineral chemistry and oxygen 
> isotopes clearly indicate that NWA 1839 and NWA 3133 are NOT paired, 
> period! bingo!"
> 
> I don't think it could be stated much clearer than that,
> 
> Adam

I have actually seen it stated more clearly than that, and the fact is 
that they are definitely paired. I'll stake my reputation on that.

David