[meteorite-list] Russia mega meteor and asteroid 2012DA14 related, yes I think so...

Bjorn Sorheim astrogeo at online.no
Sat Feb 16 03:28:55 EST 2013


I would think there would be more objects trailing a (small) asteroid, yes.
But what forces releases a smaller fragment from an asteroid/meteoroide?
Rotation, tension in the rock, gas release underneath? Some of these forces 
could
be strong and send them forwards with some speed.
I'm not shure what quantitive effect of solar wind etc.would have in the 
long run, but yes
I would think asteroids in some ways resemble the situation you have with 
comets, but the material
in the latter is of course much lighter, and a greater effect of  the solar 
wind is felt.
It's a bit beyond me, and it's very hard to observe debris clouds around 
such small objects.

Bjørn Sørheim

 >Bjorne just a quick thought, wouldn't this impact been after the fact 
given the passage of the NEO 2012DA14 instead of before >if the events were 
related?

 >Sent from my iPhone

 >On Feb 15, 2013, at 11:35 PM, Bjorn Sorheim <astrogeo at online.no> wrote:

 >>
 >> Two completely different trajectories??
 >> What the heck are you talking about?
 >> They are quite similar. It would not at this point say they are identical.
 >> In WHAT way are they _completely different_, elaborate please.
 >> And don't be so d** arrogant, for christ sake.
 >> I could mention that the foremost celest mechanican in my country says they
 >> are strangly similar, and he has been working for NASA and the 
Voyagers, and he has
 >> an asteroid named after him.
 >>
 >> Bjørn Sørheim
 >>
 >>
 >> >It is 100% certain that the two bodies are unrelated, given the physical
 >> >impossibility of a single object producing the two completely different
 >> >trajectories involved. I'd suggest you study orbital dynamics before
 >> >making scientifically unsound suggestions.
 >>
 >> >NASA has made no "final verdict". It's initial analysis is no different
 >> >than what dozens of other meteor experts have concluded.
 >>
 >> >Chris
 >>
 >> >*******************************
 >> >Chris L Peterson
 >> >Cloudbait Observatory




More information about the Meteorite-list mailing list