[meteorite-list] Hunt Goes On for More Meteorites

[Michael Mulgrew]

George, here's what you're missing:

There is a difference between keeping an area you are recovering
meteorites from a secret, and painting anyone not affiliated with the
NASA "team" as a rogue operative working against science.  The NASA
"team" failed to identify the meteorite initially (which I still find
absurd after seeing more pictures), and if it wasn't for the "rogue
hunter" who DID sell some of his find on eBay scientists would have
NOTHING to study right now.

A rogue hunter,

Michael in so. Cal.


GeoZay
Sat, 03 Nov 2012 08:21:39 -0700

"Rivera said he took an oath not to tell  what they saw for fear that
rogue meteorite hunters — eager to sell galactic  collectibles on eBay
— might pounce on new potential meteorite locations and  rob scientists'
ability to research more rocks."



Maybe I'm  missing something here, but from sitting on the side, I've
gotten the impression  that its standard practice for various meteorite hunters
to hide their hot spots  from each other until the "cat is pretty much out of
the bag."  I think it  was on the first episode of Meteorite Men they
talked about keeping the location  of Pallasite finds secret. I also think on
another episode, a hunting site in  Nevada was also suppose to been kept
secret. On occasions I've read on this list  where individual hunters or
various
groups would hint at not mentioning where  they are etc. while searching for
a new strewnfield. I honestly don't think  Jenniskens is doing anything
different for his interests, than what the rest of  the meteorite hunting world
is doing for themselves or group.
George Zay