[meteorite-list] What's in a name
    Rob Matson 
    mojave_meteorites at cox.net
       
    Mon Feb 23 02:07:18 EST 2009
    
    
  
Hi Steve,
> If it really is customary to avoid choosing proper names that are a subset
> of existing ones, how in the world did Clearwater West, Kelly West,
Laundry
> West, Victoria West, West Hawk, West Point all avoid the custom of
> disqualification on the above merits?
Ahh, but they are not subsets of one another -- they merely share parts of
their
names. "Point" would be a subset of "West Point", or "Hawk" a subset of
"West
Hawk". (There is no "Hawk" meteorite or "Point" meteorite). That said, I'm
sure
that if one digs through all the meteorite names, examples can be found that
make your case, but if confusion can be avoided, why not do so?
--Rob
    
    
More information about the Meteorite-list
mailing list