[meteorite-list] Extreme melting event defines Earth's early history

[Darren Garrison]

http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2005-06/ci-eme061505.php

Extreme melting event defines Earth's early history
Could Earth have had an even more violent infancy than previously imagined? New isotope data suggest
that the Earth not only had a very violent beginning but also point to new information about our
planet's chemical evolution.
New and precise measurements of a neodymium isotope ratio (142Nd/144Nd) led Maud Boyet and Rick
Carlson of Carnegie Institution's Department of Terrestrial Magnetism to the discovery that all
terrestrial rocks have an excess of 142Nd compared to the expected building blocks of the planet.
The results will appear in the June 16, 2005 edition of Science.

Prior research suggested that the Earth formed by the accumulation of planetesimals -- small cold
bodies present in early solar system history. The chemical composition of these early bodies is
reflected today in a type of stony meteorite called chondrites. Scientists had expected that the
Earth would have a composition similar to these meteorites. However, this new research challenges
these earlier conclusions by showing that terrestrial rocks have excess 142Nd caused by the
radioactive decay of the now extinct isotope 146Sm. 

One possible explanation of the difference in 142Nd/144Nd between Earth and chondrites is that the
Earth's average composition is not chondritic, but on the basis of several chemical arguments this
explanation is unlikely. More probable is that the portion of the Earth involved in creating crustal
rocks was chemically differentiated very early in the planet's history – Boyet and Carlson's results
suggest within the first 30 million years, or less than 1%, of Earth's history. As such, this
evidence fits the growing number of observations from the Moon and Mars that the early history of
planets was a very violent one, where collisions with planetesimals, the release of radioactive
heat, and the energy involved in separating a metallic core all provide enough energy to melt the
planet. Cooling and crystallization of the molten planet over timescales of millions to a few tens
of millions of years then result in its chemical differentiation, segregating material according to
density. This differentiation left most of the Earth's mantle similar in composition to the
present-day upper mantle from which volcanic rocks are derived.

There must then be material that is complementary in composition to the bulk of the mantle. This
complementary region, if the Earth is to have an average composition matching chondrites, must be
enriched in potassium, uranium, and thorium -- radioactive elements that have provided most of the
heat generation in the Earth's interior throughout its history. Furthermore, this complementary
mantle reservoir must be very deep, because none of the magmas that have erupted at the Earth's
surface have ever sampled it. Boyet and Carlson suggest that the reservoir coincides with the
so-called D" layer imaged seismically at the very base of the mantle, just above the core. A
radioactive-element-rich layer deep in the Earth is like a heating plate at the bottom of a pot: it
will keep the bottom of the pot hot for a long time. Such a layer will also keep the top of the core
hot and hence delay its cooling and crystallization. The scientists postulate that the early
differentiation of the Earth and the deep layer produced by that process may be the reason that the
Earth still has its magnetic field. The deep layer may also be responsible for generating hot plumes
of upwelling mantle material that give rise to volcanic island chains such as Hawaii.