[meteorite-list] A Call For A New Meteorite List

[AL Mitterling]

Hi Jim and all,

I certainly agree with what you have to say and wish that the rules 
would be honored for the most part (I doubt there will ever be a perfect 
forum). In reality when list members have approached Art on this, it 
seems to fall on deaf ears. Art could certainly appoint someone to keep 
things reasonably civil, maybe contacting offending parties before 
action would be taken. However to date nothing like this has ever happened.

Those claiming censorship probably don't agree that we have police on 
the streets to enforce laws so, (a) they don't hurt themselves, (b) they 
don't hurt others and (c) are removed from the streets when they don't 
get the message.

There has been a group of people who have been suggesting a new list 
with a moderator. I think that we would get a core group of people from 
the old list and past members. When the suggestion was made about two 
months ago in a private email, there was an overwhelming support by 
those getting this private email. Bernd posted some of the comments when 
people were fighting on the list last round.

People that want to sling mud would stay on the current list and some 
would probably remain on both lists but if we can generate something of 
quality then maybe we could bring the bulk of the meteorite list to the 
new list and leave the trouble makers behind.

Wishing we had more gentleman as yourself Jim!

--AL


Jim Strope wrote:

> Al..........
> 
> While I certainly agree that the flame wars etc. make this list 
> virtually a joke, I do not think a new list would catch on to the point 
> where it would replace this list.  It has just been around too long.  I 
> think the answer is to fix what we have.


 > THIS LIST NEEDS RULES WITH TEETH!!!!!!!
 >
 > Jim Strope
 > 421 Fourth Street
 > Glen Dale, WV  26038